God Giving Descartes a Golden Tablet with the Inscription “I think therefore I am.” by Gemini

Member-only story

Debunking “God Gave Us Reason”

Reason Is Immaterial and Came from God, Right??

Tony Berard
20 min readDec 23, 2024

--

This is a discussion I had with Google Gemini Pro 1.5, and I debunked the claim that reason is immaterial. How did I do — and to its satisfaction? It’s all here in this article!!

Can you summarize and explain the following video, please?

The video, The Hidden Problem with EVERY Atheist Argument, Unsolicited Advice discusses the theistic argument that atheism cannot support the use of reason. This argument is based on the idea that in a materialistic worldview, there are only causes and no reasons. The video begins by summarizing the argument and explaining why some people find it compelling. It then explores several responses to the argument, including the idea that reason can be grounded in something material, such as the laws of logic or the structure of the human brain. The video also discusses the argument from evolution, which claims that evolution does not support the existence of reason. Finally, the video explores the possibility of non-materialist atheism, which is the belief that there are…

--

--

Tony Berard
Tony Berard

Written by Tony Berard

I have lately been constructing arguments against God and the supernatural. I have proven that stuff doesn't exist with science equations. I aspire to be great.

Responses (1)